I’m trying to teach my students how to give meaningful and constructive design feedback that’s not just “I like it” What are some tips you’d share with them?
Here’s the structure for how I run design crits + template I hand out to participants to use (shamelessly lifted from a previous job)
I love the rules and instructions listed on the template too. Especially: - critique must pertain to a specific design principle the author has predefined - round robin style, 1 feedback item per person, then next person goes (🔁) - if someone mentioned a point, don’t repeat it
Actually I'll just share a real deck for a design crit I ran in the design phase of a specific initiative at Trustpilot (an independent platform for customer reviews). Only omission is a slide w/Very Secret Business Metrics files.jonas.so/design-crit-ex…
My pleasure! If you find an opportunity to try it out in a crit session, I’d be super happy to hear your thoughts