I have a list of where I put stuff after I hear 3 people (critics, folks like on here, friend and family, or mix between all) praise it to me independent of each other

What do you mean by critics, like movie experts online?

Yeah either or. I just want 3 independent sources singing its praises kinda unprompted then I commit to it via The List

The UX could be so much better, but generally I think metacritic.com is great for this.

Didn’t know this one before—bookmarked. Is this the only way you discover new things to watch?

David Ehrlich’s top 25 countdowns! videocountdowns.com/