Posts, a community app by Read.cv

Thread
Stas Moor
Replying to @nickisnoble

Just wondering why the negativity towards bento? I am biased and therefore want to know. 🙂

Nick Noble
Replying to @stasmoor

➊ Over used as a shortcut when it’s not always the best choice ➋ Apple does things that are great for Apple, and other people like it, and then don’t make anything new. Now everything tastes the same. ➌ *old man yells at cloud* IT’S CALLED A MODULAR GRID

Stas Moor
Replying to @nickisnoble

Thank you for your perspective on this. I guess it’s like with everything else that is “trendy”. Be it a color, a design approach, illustration style, etc. people will take those shortcuts, sometimes without thinking why. And the sameness is also something that saddens me.

William M.
Replying to @stasmoor @nickisnoble

I think part of the people are just saturated of this trend becaus it's everywhere, but honestly, it hurts only to look at it. There is so much information, so much "pop-up", and the way of reading it feels so awkward and overwhelming, as if I was looking at a old newspaper.

Nick Noble
Replying to @willisenough @stasmoor

Yes, @@paddelmentioned they are great for summaries (which is what Apple designed them for!) But I think, as a trend, they are used as a shortcut for everything else rather than actually figuring out IA.

Nick Noble
Replying to @paddel @willisenough @stasmoor

@stasmoor IDK if you want site feedback but IMO your site falls into that category - each cell is individually *super aesthetic* but the broad composition completely relies on the bento for cohesion! Wayfinding / direction is lost, and could be wonderful given what you’ve got.

Nick Noble
Replying to @stasmoor @paddel @willisenough

(Still a lovely site, minor note since we’re on the subject. You’ve seared the perfect steak, and served it in tupperware! Steak is still good but you’ve missed an opportunity for presentation)

Stas Moor
Replying to @nickisnoble @paddel @willisenough

Thank you for your honest feedback, I respect it. 🤝 What is important, are the goals that went into it, i.e. I actually want the steak to be in a Tupperware, as this way it’s easier to take home. 😄 Furthermore, I fully understand that it won’t be to everyone’s taste.

Nick Noble
Replying to @stasmoor @paddel @willisenough

Really well put!

Stas Moor
Replying to @nickisnoble @paddel @willisenough

🤝